Well, I am FOR SURE now! It works!!!!! Its alive!
here is my pf.conf
Essentially I just swapped the order of the stuff. Go figure...
# Setup a variable for who IS allowed to go online
# Default Rules
pass out quick on $LAN all
pass in on $LAN from any to 126.96.36.199/32
pass in quick on $LAN from $FullInternetIPs to any
pass in quick on $LAN from any to $SBC
pass in quick on $LAN from any to $DNS
pass in quick on $LAN from any to $MAPQUEST
block in log on $LAN all
But thanks again Ashcrow, GnuVince, and Noblestknight! Appreciate the assistance!